Team Select:
| Year | Team Name | Record | Rank | Results | |
| 1899 | Louisville Colonels | 75-77 | 9th | NL | |
| 1898 | Louisville Colonels | 70-81 | 9th | NL | |
| 1897 | Louisville Colonels | 52-78 | 11th | NL | |
| 1896 | Louisville Colonels | 38-93 | 12th | NL | |
| 1895 | Louisville Colonels | 35-96 | 12th | NL | |
| 1894 | Louisville Colonels | 36-94 | 12th | NL | |
| 1893 | Louisville Colonels | 50-75 | 11th | NL | |
| 1892 | Louisville Colonels | 63-89 | 9th | NL | |
| 1891 | Louisville Colonels | 54-83 | 8th | AA | |
| 1890 | Louisville Colonels | 88-44 | 1st | AA | AACS |
| 1889 | Louisville Colonels | 27-111 | 8th | AA | |
| 1888 | Louisville Colonels | 48-87 | 7th | AA | |
| 1887 | Louisville Colonels | 76-60 | 4th | AA | |
| 1886 | Louisville Colonels | 66-70 | 4th | AA | |
| 1885 | Louisville Colonels | 53-59 | 6th | AA | |
| 1884 | Louisville Eclipse | 68-40 | 3rd | AA | |
| 1883 | Louisville Eclipse | 52-45 | 5th | AA | |
| 1882 | Louisville Eclipse | 42-38 | 2nd | AA | |